Andrew Barker KC

Profile

Andrew has been in practice as a barrister sole since 2002.  He was appointed a Queens Counsel in 2017.  He formerly worked in the litigation department of Russell McVeagh and lectured at the University of Otago.  


Andrew has a broad practice encompassing most areas of commercial litigation.  He has particular experience in the areas of property law, trusts, contract and tort, and more general corporate and shareholder disputes.  He has been counsel in many of the leading cases in these areas.


Andrew is also increasingly asked to act as an arbitrator or provide determinations in respect of commercial disputes.  He accepts instructions in these areas.  


Andrew is a regular presenter of seminars for the legal profession.  He presents the national seminar “Tort Law Update” for NZLS CLE on a regular basis.  He has also recently presented an update on “Property Law Litigation” and took part in the “Property Law Intensive” for the NZLS CLE.

Profile

Andrew has been in practice as a barrister sole since 2002.  He was appointed a Queens Counsel in 2017.  He formerly worked in the litigation department of Russell McVeagh and lectured at the University of Otago.  


Andrew has a broad practice encompassing most areas of commercial litigation.  He has particular experience in the areas of property law, trusts, contract and tort, and more general corporate and shareholder disputes.  He has been counsel in many of the leading cases in these areas.


Andrew is also increasingly asked to act as an arbitrator or provide determinations in respect of commercial disputes.  He accepts instructions in these areas.  


Andrew is a regular presenter of seminars for the legal profession.  He presents the national seminar “Tort Law Update” for NZLS CLE on a regular basis.  He has also recently presented an update on “Property Law Litigation” and took part in the “Property Law Intensive” for the NZLS CLE.

Profile

Andrew has been in practice as a barrister sole since 2002.  He was appointed a Queens Counsel in 2017.  He formerly worked in the litigation department of Russell McVeagh and lectured at the University of Otago.  


Andrew has a broad practice encompassing most areas of commercial litigation.  He has particular experience in the areas of property law, trusts, contract and tort, and more general corporate and shareholder disputes.  He has been counsel in many of the leading cases in these areas.


Andrew is also increasingly asked to act as an arbitrator or provide determinations in respect of commercial disputes.  He accepts instructions in these areas.  


Andrew is a regular presenter of seminars for the legal profession.  He presents the national seminar “Tort Law Update” for NZLS CLE on a regular basis.  He has also recently presented an update on “Property Law Litigation” and took part in the “Property Law Intensive” for the NZLS CLE.

Additional information

Case History
  • Financial Markets Authority v Zhong [2024] NZHC 2126 – jurisdiction to order indemnity costs under Financial Markets Conduct Act (Amicus appointment).  
  • BA Trustees Ltd v Druskovich [2024] NZHC 2021 – determination of rights in respect of right of way.  
  • Lessor v Management Company – private arbitration to determine nature and extent of management rights for large inner-City apartment building.  
  • Tisot v Selak [2024] NZHC 1300 - cancellation and modification of land covenants.  
  • Martelli v Liow [2024] NZHC 968 - appeal from arbitral award (now leading authority on development rights under cross-leases).  
  • 100 Investments v Walker – various claims by creditors of the PVL group against liquidator and litigation funder arising out of the settlement of litigation on behalf of PVL.  
  • Airport Authority v Land Owner – private arbitration to determine rent reviews.  
  • Johnstone v Alpha Insurance a/s (in bankruptcy) [2024] NZHC 725 – CBL liquidation.  Entitlement of liquidators to set aside payments as a voidable preference.
  • Tauranga City Council v Harrison Grierson Holdings Ltd [2024] NZHC 714 –enforceability of limitation clauses in construction contracts
  • Chen v Huang [2024] NZCA 38 – determination of rights on the unwinding of a joint venture.  
  • Freer v Earthquake Commission – [2023] NZHC 1301, 3662 - certification of class action against EQC by owners of properties affected by Christchurch Earthquake.
  • Young v Attorney-General [2023] 2 NZLR 24 (CA), [2023] 1 NZLR 596 (SC) – liability in nuisance for naturally occurring hazards on neighbour’s property (unstable cliffs).  
  • Pfisterer v Claims Resolution Service Ltd [2023] 3 NZLR 533 – various claims based on alleged misleading and deceptive conduct, and breach of fiduciary duty, relating to litigation funding arrangement.  Test case for proceeding in Claims Resolution Service Ltd v Smith [2020] NZCA 664 and Harris v Smith [2022] NZCA 313 (and various other hearings).  
  • Colville v Colville [2023] NZHC 2659 – breach of restraint of trade, inducing breach of contract, following sale of interest in substantial building company franchise.    
  • FAI Money Ltd v Vujcich (as executor of estate of Martens) [2021] NZHC 2267 – vesting of property on bankruptcy.
  • Watherston v PGW Rural Capital Ltd [2020] NZCCLR 25 (CA) - limitation provisions under CCCFA.
  • Kinara Trustee Ltd v Infinity Enterprises NZ Ltd (2019) NZCPR 318 (HC); [2020] 3 NZLR 626 (CA); (2020) 21 NZCPR 616 (SC) - easement over land subject to apartment development.
  • Fox Mortimer Trust Co Ltd v MGH Trah Ltd (2020) 29 NZCPR 754 - restrictive covenants in land sale.
  • Restaurant Brands Ltd v Forsgren NZ Ltd [2019] NZHC 602 - dispute over terms of sale of Carl's Junior chain of stores.
  • GP96 Ltd v PVG Securities Trustee Ltd (2019) 20 NZCPR 809 (CA) - allocation of insurance proceeds to reinstatement of commercial premises.
  • Public Trust v Kain (2019) 5 NZTR 29-019 - beneficiary/trustee dispute.
  • Young v AG [2019] NZAR 1015 - claim in nuisance against Crown following Christchurch earthquakes.
  • Detection Services Ltd v Pickering [2019] NZAR 515 - competing claims over failure of joint venture.
  • Fisher v Faa Gu [2018] NZAR 1795 - enforceability of claims against trustees.
  • Custom Street Hotel Ltd v Plus Construction Ltd [2018] 3 NZLR 34 (CA) - termination of the construction contract relating to the construction of the Sofitel Hotel in Auckland.
  • Kawarau Village Holdings Ltd v Sun [2018] 1 NZLR 378 (CA, SC) - enforceability of sale and purchase agreements for stage 1 of the Hilton Hotel development in Queenstown.
  • Fish Man Ltd (in liq) v Hadfield [2018] 2 NZLR 428 (CA) - principles of equitable tracing and the rights of creditor to property disclaimed by the Official Assignee.
  • Activedocs Ltd v Cadre Investments Ltd (2017) 11 NZCLC 98-05 (CA) - shareholder/company dispute over the terms of a preference share issue.
  • Probus South Pacific Inc v Probus NZ Inc (2015) 114 IPR 630 – use of the Probus name by the Probus Clubs of New Zealand.
  • Yandina Investments Ltd v ANZ National Bank Ltd (2014) 26 NZTC 21-064 (HC, CA, SC) –dispute over the terms of the lease of a Boeing 747.
  • Telco 1 v Telco 2 - private arbitration over the terms of sale of telecommunications company).
  • BNZ Investments Ltd v CIR (2009) 24 NZTC 23,582 – allegations of tax avoidance on cross-border structured finance transactions.
  • Waller & Anor v Davies & Ors [2007] 2 NZLR 508 (CA, SC) - Land Transfer Act fraud and imputation of knowledge.
  • Accent Management Ltd & Ors v CIR (2005) 22 NZTC 19,027 – allegations of tax avoidance in forestry investment (the Trinity tax “scheme”).
  • Various substantial trust disputes, including Mitchell v Griffiths (removal of trustees), Re W A Stephenson Memorial Trust (variation of the Stephenson family trusts), Peacock v Nelson (removal of trustees), Calderwood v Calderwood (challenge to establishment of trusts).
  • Various substantive construction disputes, including Perpetual Trust Ltd v Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd (construction of the Botany Town Centre), Body Corporate no 338356 v Endean (construction of the Endean building), Takanini Central Residential Ltd v Terra Group NZ Ltd (dispute between Engineer and owner).
  • Various claims under the Public Works Act, including Treasury Properties Ltd v AG (offer back of land under s 40), Jaafar Holdings Ltd v Auckland Council [2018] NZLVT 8 (claim for compensation under s 60), claims by affected parties for injurious affection resulting from CRL construction works.

Other significant recent instructions

  • Acting for plaintiff creditors in various substantial corporate insolvencies.
  • Acting for defendants in class action arising out of the Christchurch earthquakes.
  • Acting for trading bank in the “bank fees” litigation.
  • Acting for major charitable institution in resolution of competing claims relating to substantive bequest.
  • Acting for affected entities in Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care.
  • Acting for trading bank in the resolution of a claim based on misleading conduct in derivatives trading.

Documents
  • Financial Markets Authority v Zhong [2024] NZHC 2126 – jurisdiction to order indemnity costs under Financial Markets Conduct Act (Amicus appointment).  
  • BA Trustees Ltd v Druskovich [2024] NZHC 2021 – determination of rights in respect of right of way.  
  • Lessor v Management Company – private arbitration to determine nature and extent of management rights for large inner-City apartment building.  
  • Tisot v Selak [2024] NZHC 1300 - cancellation and modification of land covenants.  
  • Martelli v Liow [2024] NZHC 968 - appeal from arbitral award (now leading authority on development rights under cross-leases).  
  • 100 Investments v Walker – various claims by creditors of the PVL group against liquidator and litigation funder arising out of the settlement of litigation on behalf of PVL.  
  • Airport Authority v Land Owner – private arbitration to determine rent reviews.  
  • Johnstone v Alpha Insurance a/s (in bankruptcy) [2024] NZHC 725 – CBL liquidation.  Entitlement of liquidators to set aside payments as a voidable preference.
  • Tauranga City Council v Harrison Grierson Holdings Ltd [2024] NZHC 714 –enforceability of limitation clauses in construction contracts
  • Chen v Huang [2024] NZCA 38 – determination of rights on the unwinding of a joint venture.  
  • Freer v Earthquake Commission – [2023] NZHC 1301, 3662 - certification of class action against EQC by owners of properties affected by Christchurch Earthquake.
  • Young v Attorney-General [2023] 2 NZLR 24 (CA), [2023] 1 NZLR 596 (SC) – liability in nuisance for naturally occurring hazards on neighbour’s property (unstable cliffs).  
  • Pfisterer v Claims Resolution Service Ltd [2023] 3 NZLR 533 – various claims based on alleged misleading and deceptive conduct, and breach of fiduciary duty, relating to litigation funding arrangement.  Test case for proceeding in Claims Resolution Service Ltd v Smith [2020] NZCA 664 and Harris v Smith [2022] NZCA 313 (and various other hearings).  
  • Colville v Colville [2023] NZHC 2659 – breach of restraint of trade, inducing breach of contract, following sale of interest in substantial building company franchise.    
  • FAI Money Ltd v Vujcich (as executor of estate of Martens) [2021] NZHC 2267 – vesting of property on bankruptcy.
  • Watherston v PGW Rural Capital Ltd [2020] NZCCLR 25 (CA) - limitation provisions under CCCFA.
  • Kinara Trustee Ltd v Infinity Enterprises NZ Ltd (2019) NZCPR 318 (HC); [2020] 3 NZLR 626 (CA); (2020) 21 NZCPR 616 (SC) - easement over land subject to apartment development.
  • Fox Mortimer Trust Co Ltd v MGH Trah Ltd (2020) 29 NZCPR 754 - restrictive covenants in land sale.
  • Restaurant Brands Ltd v Forsgren NZ Ltd [2019] NZHC 602 - dispute over terms of sale of Carl's Junior chain of stores.
  • GP96 Ltd v PVG Securities Trustee Ltd (2019) 20 NZCPR 809 (CA) - allocation of insurance proceeds to reinstatement of commercial premises.
  • Public Trust v Kain (2019) 5 NZTR 29-019 - beneficiary/trustee dispute.
  • Young v AG [2019] NZAR 1015 - claim in nuisance against Crown following Christchurch earthquakes.
  • Detection Services Ltd v Pickering [2019] NZAR 515 - competing claims over failure of joint venture.
  • Fisher v Faa Gu [2018] NZAR 1795 - enforceability of claims against trustees.
  • Custom Street Hotel Ltd v Plus Construction Ltd [2018] 3 NZLR 34 (CA) - termination of the construction contract relating to the construction of the Sofitel Hotel in Auckland.
  • Kawarau Village Holdings Ltd v Sun [2018] 1 NZLR 378 (CA, SC) - enforceability of sale and purchase agreements for stage 1 of the Hilton Hotel development in Queenstown.
  • Fish Man Ltd (in liq) v Hadfield [2018] 2 NZLR 428 (CA) - principles of equitable tracing and the rights of creditor to property disclaimed by the Official Assignee.
  • Activedocs Ltd v Cadre Investments Ltd (2017) 11 NZCLC 98-05 (CA) - shareholder/company dispute over the terms of a preference share issue.
  • Probus South Pacific Inc v Probus NZ Inc (2015) 114 IPR 630 – use of the Probus name by the Probus Clubs of New Zealand.
  • Yandina Investments Ltd v ANZ National Bank Ltd (2014) 26 NZTC 21-064 (HC, CA, SC) –dispute over the terms of the lease of a Boeing 747.
  • Telco 1 v Telco 2 - private arbitration over the terms of sale of telecommunications company).
  • BNZ Investments Ltd v CIR (2009) 24 NZTC 23,582 – allegations of tax avoidance on cross-border structured finance transactions.
  • Waller & Anor v Davies & Ors [2007] 2 NZLR 508 (CA, SC) - Land Transfer Act fraud and imputation of knowledge.
  • Accent Management Ltd & Ors v CIR (2005) 22 NZTC 19,027 – allegations of tax avoidance in forestry investment (the Trinity tax “scheme”).
  • Various substantial trust disputes, including Mitchell v Griffiths (removal of trustees), Re W A Stephenson Memorial Trust (variation of the Stephenson family trusts), Peacock v Nelson (removal of trustees), Calderwood v Calderwood (challenge to establishment of trusts).
  • Various substantive construction disputes, including Perpetual Trust Ltd v Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd (construction of the Botany Town Centre), Body Corporate no 338356 v Endean (construction of the Endean building), Takanini Central Residential Ltd v Terra Group NZ Ltd (dispute between Engineer and owner).
  • Various claims under the Public Works Act, including Treasury Properties Ltd v AG (offer back of land under s 40), Jaafar Holdings Ltd v Auckland Council [2018] NZLVT 8 (claim for compensation under s 60), claims by affected parties for injurious affection resulting from CRL construction works.

Other significant recent instructions

  • Acting for plaintiff creditors in various substantial corporate insolvencies.
  • Acting for defendants in class action arising out of the Christchurch earthquakes.
  • Acting for trading bank in the “bank fees” litigation.
  • Acting for major charitable institution in resolution of competing claims relating to substantive bequest.
  • Acting for affected entities in Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care.
  • Acting for trading bank in the resolution of a claim based on misleading conduct in derivatives trading.

Publications and Seminars
  • "Tort Law Update", NZLS CLE Seminar (June 2022) (with Professor Geoff McLay).
  • "Property Law Intensive", NZLS CLE Seminar (June 2022).
  • "Property Law Litigation", NZLS CLE Seminar (February 2022).
  • "Tort Law Update", NZLS CLE Seminar (September 2019) (with Professor Geoff McLay).
  • "Update on Negligent Misstatement", ADLS (2017) (with Marcus Roberts).
  • “Tort Law Update”, NZLS CLE Seminar (April 2016) (with Professor Geoff McLay).
  • “Issues in Unjust Enrichment”, NZLS CLE Seminar (2014).
  • “Advocacy”, presentation to participants in the NZLS mooting contest (2014), (2015).
  • "Kembla and the Defendant Summary Judgment: Is the Emperor wearing any clothes?" (2013) NZ Lawyer Issue 204
  • “One test to rule them all (and of inferior courts to bind them)” (2012) NZ Lawyer Issue 190.
  • “Tort Law”, NZLS CLE Seminar (2013) (with Professor Stephen Todd).
  • Chapter on "Permanent Injunctions", in Blanchard ed, Civil Remedies in New Zealand (1st ed) (2003); (2nd ed) (2011).
  • Chapter on "Interlocutory Injunctions", in Blanchard ed, Civil Remedies in New Zealand (1st ed) (2003); (2nd ed) (2011).
  • “General Principles of Good Advocacy”, ADLS CLE Seminar (2011).
  • "Remoteness of damages in tort and contract", in "Current issues in remedies", NZLS CLE Seminar (2010).
  • "Economics of Evidence, Procedure and Litigation", (Book review) [2009] NZLJ 330.
  • Commentary on papers by Dr A Butler ("What is the least we can expect of a trustee?") and Bill Patterson ("When is a trust a trust?") at the Legal Research Foundation Seminar, "A modern law of trusts" (2009).
  • "Update on Tort Law", ADLS CLE Seminar (2008).
  • "Damages for a loss of chance in negligence: the availability of an alternative remedy" [2007] NZLJ 151.
  • "Update on Tort Law", ADLS CLE Seminar (2006).
  • "Damages for the loss of a chance: the availability of an alternative remedy", LexisNexis Commercial Litigation Masterclass (2005).
  • "Update on Tort Law: The approach to the duty of care in New Zealand", ADLS CLE Seminar (2003).
  • "The duty of care and the search for certainty: Sullivan v Moody, Cooper v Hobart, and problems in the South Pacific" [2003] NZLJ 44.
  • "Ideas on the purpose of civil procedure" [2002] New Zealand Law Review 437.
  • "Lights in the fog: secondary victims and the recovery for mental injury in New Zealand" (2002) 10 Tort Law Review 1.
  • "Divining an approach to the duty of care: the New Zealand Court of Appeal and claims for negligent misstatement" (2001) 10 OLR 91.
  • "Causation and Risk in the Law of Torts" (Book review) (2000) 19 NZULR 136.
Professional Activities
  • Barrister assisting Auckland Community Law Centre bankruptcy advice service
  • Queens Counsel - 2017
  • Barrister - 2002 to present
  • Lecturer - Faculty of Law, University of Otago - 1999 to 2001
  • Senior Litigation Solicitor - Russell McVeagh (Auckland) - 1994 to 1998
  • Clerk to Judges of the New Zealand Court of Appeal - 1995
  • Solicitor at Community Law Centre in Mangere (through Russell McVeagh) - 1995 to 1996

Teaching

  • Civil Litigation - LLB course - University of Otago - 2008 to 2009
  • Civil Procedure - LLB course - University of Otago - 2006
  • Tort Law - LLM course - University of Auckland - 2003
  • The Law of Torts - LLB course - University of Otago - 2000 to 2002
  • Civil Procedure - LLB course - University of Otago - 2001 to 2002
  • Property Law - LLB course - University of Otago (tutor) - 2000 to 2002

Qualifications

BA LLB (Hons) (Auck) 1994

LLM (Toronto) 1999

Barrister Sole: 2002

Queens Counsel: 2017

Andrew
Barker KC
ab@shortlandchambers.co.nz
+64 21 744 575
+64 9 354 1416
Shortland Chambers